Card fees and charging the card on file
Nov 19, 2026
Card rules let RedBird pass its card cost to the buyer, but not add a margin on top. We recommend charging the card fee at cost, on credit cards only, and earning RedBird's margin through the buyer's premium.
For the card on file, we recommend one charge on day 15, only if the invoice is still unpaid, with the bidder's consent at registration and reminders around day 7 and day 12.
Agreed on 18 Nov: the buyer pays the card fee, and charging the card on file for an unpaid invoice is acceptable. Also raised: a margin for RedBird on card and PayPal payments, and when the card on file is charged. Card rules shape all three.
What the card rules say
From Visa's U.S. merchant surcharging Q&A (version of 15 Feb 2024):
The fee is capped at RedBird's own cost for that card, and at 3%: "Limit the amount to your merchant discount rate (MDR) for the applicable credit card or 3% whichever is lowest".
Credit cards only: "debit cards and prepaid cards cannot be surcharged".
Some states prohibit it: Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, Oklahoma and Puerto Rico; Colorado, Minnesota, New Jersey and New York add their own requirements (Visa's list as of Feb 2024).
Notice and disclosure: 30 days' notice before the first surcharge; the fee shown where the buyer starts, at checkout, and as its own line on the receipt.
Mastercard and PayPal work the same way:
Mastercard: a cap of 4%, and never more than the merchant's cost to accept that card; no fee on debit or prepaid cards.
PayPal (US User Agreement): "you will not impose a surcharge or any other fee for accepting PayPal as a payment method". A margin on PayPal payments cannot come from a PayPal fee.
| House | Card fee |
|---|---|
| Heritage | 2.9%, card payment by prior approval; "does not exceed Auctioneer's cost of processing" |
| RR Auction | 3%; cards only for small invoices |
| Phillips New York | 2.5% "convenience fee" |
| Propstore | 2% plus VAT in its London sale terms; 2.5% in its US sale terms as published on LiveAuctioneers |
Two ways to set it
| A · Card fee at cost (recommended) | B · Card cost inside the premium | |
|---|---|---|
| How it works | Credit-card payers pay RedBird's card cost, up to 3% | One buyer's premium covers card costs; bank transfers get a discount |
| Where RedBird's margin sits | In the buyer's premium | In the premium, plus any saving from lower card rates |
| A lower card rate from negotiation | Lowers the fee for collectors | Becomes RedBird's margin |
| Debit and the restricted states | RedBird pays those card costs | Same price everywhere |
| What collectors are used to | The fee they see at Heritage, RR and Phillips | A higher headline premium |
We recommend A at launch: it is what collectors see at the houses above, and it keeps "the buyer pays" visible. RedBird's margin comes from the premium, and a negotiated card rate can keep RedBird's fee below the 2% to 3% charged elsewhere. B is the route if RedBird wants the card-rate saving itself.
How the fee is worked out
Before the buyer confirms, the platform reads whether the card is credit, debit or prepaid, and adds the fee only to credit cards.
For the fee to follow each card's actual cost, RedBird's payment account needs interchange-plus pricing, where the provider passes on each card's real cost. We will ask for it when the account is set up. On standard pricing every card costs the same, so the fee is one rate at or below that cost, capped at 3%.
The fee is shown before payment, sent to the card network as a surcharge and printed as its own line on the receipt.
On a refund, the fee is refunded in proportion.
Charging the card on file
We recommend Option A: one charge on day 15, only if the invoice is still unpaid, with consent at registration and two reminders before it. A declined charge goes into the underbidder flow.
The decision
Agreed on 18 Nov: the winner's card on file may be charged, within the $10,000 card-only cap. Open: when.
A · After the 14 days to pay, if the invoice is still unpaid.
B · A hold at the close, charged if the invoice is unpaid.
C · A charge at the close.
What you told us
"14 days for auctions" and "Maybe we just start at 14 to keep it consistent up front" (16 Nov)
"I mean, that's what they're agreeing to by bidding." (18 Nov)
"we're not trying to give people something over 14 days" (18 Nov)
How other houses do it
Every house below that charges a stored card for an auction invoice does it when its payment window ends, never at the close. Only eBay and Whatnot charge at once, and they are marketplaces, not invoice businesses. Pages read 19 Nov 2026 unless marked.
| House | When the card is charged | Which invoices | What the bidder is told |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hake's | "on the 15th day following the close of the auction" | Orders under $5,000 | A check, money order or wire must arrive before the charge date |
| Sotheby's | "three business days after the sale closes", in designated auctions | Invoices below 25,000 (USD in New York) | The bidder picks a preferred method at registration; larger invoices are paid the normal way |
| Julien's | If the invoice is not settled within 3 days | Up to $5,000 | Card stored at registration with a $1 verification hold |
| Invaluable | At the selling house's option, if unpaid "within four days of receiving your invoice" | Set by the house | Not described |
| LiveAuctioneers | The selling house picks: at once, 24 hours or 3 days after the invoice | Set by the house | In the house terms and the bid box; emails "noting exactly when the card will be charged" |
| Propstore (London sale terms) | If "not paid in full within 7 calendar days after the auction close" | Cards up to £25,000 | Agreed at registration, for this and future auctions |
| Fanatics Collect (read 17 Nov) | Once an order is overdue | Orders of $10,000 or less; larger orders get an account restriction instead | A card on file is required to bid since 14 Oct 2026 |
| Heritage | The terms allow a charge to the card on file if unpaid | Not stated | Not described as automatic |
The card covers small and mid-sized invoices and bank transfer covers large ones, which matches RedBird's $10,000 card-only cap. RedBird's 14 days is longer than most windows above, so the matching moment is the day after it ends: day 15, as at Hake's.
What the rules say
For your legal team:
Consent when the card is saved. Visa's stored-credential rules let a merchant charge a saved card later, without the cardholder present, if the cardholder agreed when it was saved. The agreement must say how the card will be used and the amount or how it is worked out; for a charge like this one, also what triggers it and the cancellation and refund policy. Changes must be notified, and Visa's rules for Europe add notice before each such charge.
One attempt. The same rules bar charging again after a decline, or after the cardholder changes payment method.
No fraud protection on the charge. A charge made without the bidder present carries no liability shift: if the cardholder disputes it, RedBird bears the loss. The consent, the reminders and the bid record are the protection, and the $10,000 cap limits the exposure.
Holds are short. A card hold lasts about 7 days on most cards, so it cannot reserve the winning amount for the 14 days to pay.
The card fee on an automatic charge. Visa wants the fee shown at checkout and on the receipt (above). An automatic charge has no checkout, so we suggest the fee sits in the buyer terms, the consent wording and the reminders. This is our reading, for your legal team to confirm.
Options compared
| A · After the 14 days, if unpaid (recommended) | B · Hold at the close | C · Charge at the close | |
|---|---|---|---|
| For collectors | The full 14 days to pay by bank transfer; reminders name the card, amount and date | Up to $10,000 of card limit locked while they arrange a transfer | No choice of payment method on card-sized lots |
| For consignors and studios | Paid by day 15 at the latest on card-sized lots | Same, unless the hold lapses first | Paid soonest |
| Revenue | Card fee only when the card pays | Same as A | Card fee on every card win; charge-and-refund costs when a buyer then pays by transfer, because the processing fee is not returned |
| Risk | The card may have expired or lack funds by day 15; a check around day 7 catches expired cards | The hold lapses after about 7 days, leaving the rest of the 14 days uncovered | Lowest payment risk |
| Operations | Reminders and one scheduled charge | Holds, releases, then a charge anyway | Refunds when buyers pay another way |
| Fits the 14 days you agreed | Yes | No: the hold ends first | No |
| Who does it | Hake's on day 15; Sotheby's, Julien's, Invaluable and Propstore at the end of shorter windows | No house we found | eBay, Whatnot |
Our recommendation and why
We recommend Option A, with notice:
At registration the bidder agrees to an automatic charge on their saved card for any invoice still unpaid after 14 days, up to the $10,000 card-only cap, card fee included.
Reminders around day 7 and day 12 name the card (last four digits), the amount and the charge date, and tell bank-transfer payers their payment must arrive before then, as Hake's does.
Around day 7, a $0 card check confirms the card is still valid and asks the bidder to update an expired or cancelled card. It does not prove the funds are there.
On day 15 the card is charged once. If the charge is declined, or the invoice is above the cap, the lot goes into the underbidder flow in Unpaid lots, underbidders and winners who walk away.
Why: it is what the houses do, it keeps the 14 days you agreed and no more, and the reminders push buyers to pay themselves, which brings fraud protection the day-15 charge lacks. Invoices within the cap are then mostly settled by day 15, so the underbidder flow mainly handles larger lots and declined cards.
The case against, and our answer. Fourteen days is long next to Sotheby's 3 business days or Propstore's 7, and an earlier charge brings cash in sooner. The 14 days was your call on 16 and 18 Nov; a per-sale setting can shorten it later for everyday timed sales, as Sotheby's uses scheduled payments only in designated auctions. Top collectors who dislike automatic charges pay by bank transfer above the cap and never meet the charge.
What we take on and what we need from you
Povio builds the consent screen with space for your legal team's wording, the reminders, the day-7 card check, the single day-15 charge, and the hand-off of declined charges to the underbidder flow, all logged on the invoice. From you: the reminder days, whether a bank transfer shown as in transit gets a short grace period, and your legal team's sign-off on the consent wording and the fee disclosure. How we measure it is in the table below.
How we measure it
| Proposal | What it moves | How we measure it |
|---|---|---|
| Card fee at cost | Payment cost per sale, and how big invoices are paid | Card fees as a share of sales; share of large invoices paid by bank transfer |
| Card on file charged | Unpaid lots within the card cap | Share of invoices paid before day 15; share of day-15 charges that succeed; disputed automatic charges; days from close to cash |
For legal
The card fee against the state rules, for option A or B.
The consent wording for the day-15 charge, against Visa's stored-card rules, and where the card fee is disclosed on an automatic charge.
What we need from you
The card fee: option A (at cost, margin in the premium) or option B (inside the premium).
The card on file: Option A (one charge on day 15 if still unpaid, with reminders), the reminder days, and any grace period for bank transfers in transit.
Sources
Read 16 to 19 Nov 2026, as marked.
Visa, U.S. Merchant Surcharge Q&A (version 15 Feb 2024). Read 17–19 Nov.
Mastercard, Merchant surcharge rules. Read 17–19 Nov.
PayPal, US User Agreement. Read 17–19 Nov.
Visa, Improving Authorization Management for Transactions with Stored Credentials (10 May 2017). Read 19 Nov.
Heritage Auctions, Terms and Conditions of Auction (rev. 8 Apr 2025), paragraph 30. Read 19 Nov.
RR Auction, Terms and Conditions. Read 19 Nov.
Phillips, Conditions of Sale, New York. Read 16 Nov.
Propstore, Live Auction Catalogue terms (London sale), conditions 7.6 and 7.10. Read 19 Nov.
Propstore US sale terms, as published on LiveAuctioneers (Propstore's own US sale pages could not be opened). Read 16 Nov.
Hake's, Terms and Conditions, section 18. Read 19 Nov.
Sotheby's, How do scheduled payments work? (updated 13 Nov 2026). Read 19 Nov.
Julien's Auctions, How to bid. Read 19 Nov.
Invaluable, Payments FAQ. Read 19 Nov.
LiveAuctioneers, What is Autopay?. Read 19 Nov.
Fanatics Collect, Payment methods. Read 17 Nov.
eBay, Unpaid item policy. Read 19 Nov.
Whatnot, Help Center. Read 16 Nov.